As if Texas getting in over the Oklahoma Sooners wasn't already infuriating enough, OU fans now have even more reason to be fuming at the selection committee for leaving the Sooners out of the NCAA Tournament.
The Sooners on Selection Sunday were the first team left out of the 68-team field despite an impressive late run that got them on the bubble. Instead of OU, SMU was the last team to sneak into the Big Dance and was paired with Miami (OH) in a First Four matchup, but before the first round of the NCAA Tournament even tipped off on Thursday, it was already made clear the Mustangs had no business being in that game over OU thanks to a lie from SMU and an absolute blunder by the committee.
B.J. Edwards injury fiasco proves committee picked wrong team between OU and SMU
When selection committee chair Keith Gill, who's also the commissioner of the Sun Belt, detailed during the CBS broadcast on Sunday what some deciding factors were in the Mustangs getting in over other bubble teams, he specifically mentioned quality of wins and the availability of SMU star player B.J. Edwards.
Edwards was key in SMU notching some its biggest wins of the season that bolstered its resume, including upsets over North Carolina and Louisville. However, Edwards suffered an injury late in the season, and it was proven SMU was a completely different team without him as the Mustangs lost five of six games down the stretch with Edwards sidelined.
Gill admitted on Selection Sunday that SMU was not a tournament-worthy team without Edwards, but then he asserted that Edwards would be back for the NCAA Tournament, which was a deciding factor in the Mustangs getting the nod over the Sooners. However, fast forward only three days later, and Edwards was still sidelined when the Mustangs took the court on Wednesday night. And it obviously mattered as SMU lost to Miami (OH) 89-79 with no business being there.
Had the committee not used Edwards' incorrect injury status, it instead would have been the Sooners playing Miami on Wednesday night.
Selection Committee Chair Keith Gill provides closer insight into this year's selection process.#MarchMadness pic.twitter.com/cYODBQfpNq
— NCAA March Madness (@MarchMadnessMBB) March 15, 2026
Injuries have unfortunately made headlines for this NCAA Tournament, especially among top national contenders. It seemed the big names like North Carolina's Caleb Wilson and Duke being without two starters would make the most impact this March Madness, but SMU not having Edwards ended up being the most consequential injury when it shouldn't have even mattered at all toward a real NCAA Tournament result considering the Mustangs should have been at home or hosting an NIT game.
Betting odds and bracket predictions will always waiver on injuries, but those are interchangeable and don't have as large of an impact as an entire program getting left out of the NCAA Tournament. Injury statuses can change by the moment, and of course a program like SMU is going to say what the committee wants to hear so it can go dancing, but Gill and his selection committee just took the Mustangs for their word to decide entire seasons for multiple programs.
Porter Moser and his OU players and the fans should feel completely wronged. Even college basketball fans of rival programs and unbiased media pointed out the blunder. Actions on the court didn't matter when making the biggest decision of the college basketball season, but only hearsay.
Oklahoma is 10x better than SMU
— Alabama Basketball (@alabamacbb) March 19, 2026
In this interview on the Selection Show, chair Keith Gill indicated that the committee's belief that BJ Edwards would be available for the NCAA Tournament tipped the balance to make SMU the last team selected. The Mustangs lost four of their last five games while Edwards was… https://t.co/LhKTzykTXD
— Seth Davis (@SethDavisHoops) March 19, 2026
Thank God SMU lied so they would get in the tournament !!!
— Joe Castiglione Jr. (@JoeCJr29) March 18, 2026
(And the committee fell for it) https://t.co/zWI53u2vAT
Investigate @SMUBasketball pic.twitter.com/6lNEBcEMJ6
— Joe Castiglione Jr. (@JoeCJr29) March 19, 2026
SMU didn’t. OU easily beats Miamioh.
— Critaper (@Critaper99) March 19, 2026
