Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer proved Saturday against South Carolina that there is nothing he can't do on a football field.
Mateer, already known for his dual-threat ability as a quarterback, showed off a new skill later in the fourth quarter of the No. 14 Sooners' 26-7 win over South Carolina. In his final play of the game before coming out, Mateer booted a surprise 40-yard punt that was placed perfectly for freshman Elijah Thomas to down on South Carolina's goal line.
The play ultimately resulted in a safety one play later when OU defensive lineman Markus Strong tackled Matt Fuller in the end zone.
John Mateer surprises with punt vs South Carolina
QB QUICK KICK TO THE ONE. ๐คฏ
โ Southeastern Conference (@SEC) October 18, 2025
DEFENSIVE SAFETY. ๐ฅ@OU_Football x ๐บ @SECNetwork pic.twitter.com/3khVyrJ27b
Before he was seen yelling every time you turn on ESPN, Pat McAfee was once a standout punter with a great social media presence that eventually made him a lot more famous than his leg ever did. McAfee was a two-time Pro Bowler as the Indianapolis Colts' punter for eight seasons. He was also an All-American at West Virginia before getting selected in the seventh round of the 2009 NFL Draft.
McAfee saw Mateer's punt and was impressed as someone who used to make a living doing that.
"GREAT punt from Mateer here," McAfee wrote in a post on X.
GREAT punt from Mateer here #ForTheBrand https://t.co/RCXAFnb4WO
โ Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) October 18, 2025
McAfee wasn't the only one impressed by Mateer's dime of a punt, though. OU fans couldn't believe Mateer has yet another skill up his sleeve after leading college football with 44 total touchdowns last season.
Lol, looked like the thumb didn't bother Mateer at all on that POOCH PUNT. WHAT. He dinked it down to the 1-yard line, where Elijah Thomas killed it. Crazy.
โ John E. Hoover ๐ฎ (@johnehoover) October 18, 2025
Me talking about John Mateer after that perfect punt. pic.twitter.com/JOe7EiBxpA
โ Jacked Kerouac (@Jack3dKerouac) October 18, 2025
JOHN MATEER CAN PUNT TOO? lol
โ Tattoo Baker ๐ฅโจ (@QB1TATT00) October 18, 2025
John Mateer for the Ray Guy award
โ Boomer Beamer (@ImDerBatman) October 18, 2025
JOHN MATEER IS AN ALL AMERICAN LEVEL PUNTER
โ Owen Pannell (@SirPannell) October 18, 2025
Mateer said after the game that it was the first time he punted since middle school. OU offensive coordinator also joked that it was Mateer's best highlight after throwing for just 150 yards and a touchdown and admitted that it's apparently been on the play sheet all season.
Ben Arbuckle jokes that John Mateerโs punt was his best highlight of the game. #Sooners pic.twitter.com/XNaAyioJ7T
โ George Stoia III (@GeorgeStoia) October 18, 2025